Should Cabinet Knobs and Pulls Match My Faucet and Lighting?

This is one of the most common questions we hear—and it makes perfect sense. With so many finishes and fixtures to choose from, how do you tie everything together without making it feel too matchy-matchy?

The Short Answer? Not Always.

Your hardware, faucet, and lighting don’t have to match—but they should complement one another. The goal is to create visual harmony, not perfect uniformity. Think of it like jewellery: mixing metals can look curated and intentional when done right.

Three Approaches That Work

1. Match Everything for a Clean Look

Choosing the same finish for your pulls, faucet, and lighting (like all matte black or all brushed nickel) creates a unified, minimalist feel—great for modern or small spaces.

2. Mix but Stay Balanced

Designers often mix finishes—but in a thoughtful way. For example:

• Brushed brass pulls with a matte black faucet and black-framed mirror
• Polished nickel faucet with crystal knobs and satin brass sconces
  The trick? Repeat each finish at least once so nothing feels like the odd one out.

3. Let One Element Be the Standout

Want to make a statement? Choose one finish (like your faucet) as the star, and let other elements take a quieter role. This works especially well with bold, sculptural lighting or unique cabinet hardware.

Tips From the Designer’s Eye

• Choose finishes with similar undertones (cool vs. warm) to keep the palette cohesive
• Keep metal sheens consistent (e.g., mix brushed with brushed—not brushed with polished)
• In open-concept spaces, carry at least one finish throughout adjoining rooms for flow

Final Thoughts

You don’t need a perfect match—you need a thoughtful mix. If the finishes feel intentional and work together in tone and texture, your space will feel cohesive and elevated.

Need help deciding between styles or finishes? Laurie, JSL Hardware’s in-house designer (and the author of this blog), offers both online and in-home design consultations to support you in making the right selections. 

Laurie Orsino
JSL Hardware In-House Designer